This is a frequently asked question: what are the advantages and disadvantages of riding electric bikes over electric scooters? Both have advantages and downsides and are appropriate for persons of varying abilities. In this post, we’ll compare the two, looking at cost, range, speed, comfort, and practicality to help you determine the best for you.
Price
Electric bikes range in price from roughly £500 to well over £5000 (or $500 to over $5,000 in the United States), depending on the brand, features, and construction quality. High-end devices may have a longer battery life, better components, and more advanced functions, whilst budget ones may have more essential characteristics.
Electric scooters are often less expensive than e-bikes, with costs ranging from £200 to over £3000 for high-performance versions ($200 to over $3,000 in the United States). Prices will vary substantially depending on the engine power, battery capacity, components, and extra scooter features.
Electric scooters are the clear winners in this category. E-bikes are fantastic, but in terms of pricing, they cannot match. You must choose a higher-performance model before e-scooters are always the less expensive alternative. Typically, low-cost electric bikes have limited functionality and few batteries.
Range
The range of an electric bike is determined by parameters such as battery capacity, rider weight, topography, rider pedalling effort, and pedal assistance level. Most e-bikes range from 20 to 70 miles per charge, but you can always pedal to your destination if you run out of battery juice.
Unlike an electric bike, which uses a combination of motor power and pedalling input from the user, e-scooters rely exclusively on the motor and often have a lesser range than e-bikes, averaging roughly 10 to 30 miles per charge. As a result, they are better suited for shorter commutes and city visits. If your scooter’s battery runs out of juice, you must push it home.
Electric bikes are the clear victor in this category. If you want a long-range e-scooter, you’ll have to pay much money, and it’ll be large and heavy. You may increase the range of an e-bike by pedalling and utilizing lower power levels. E-scooters, on the other hand, do not have this privilege.
Speed
Electric bikes are legally limited to a peak speed of 15.5 mph in the United Kingdom and up to 28 mph in the United States (depending on the class and local legislation). As a result, they are faster than other electric scooters, allowing for shorter travel durations. You may also cycle past the motor’s cut-off point if you like.
Most electric scooters have max speeds ranging from 15 to 25 miles per hour. Although slower than e-bikes, they are nonetheless faster than walking. Some high-performance electric scooters may achieve up to 60 miles per hour, but these are exceptionally niche for adrenaline addicts.
Electric bikes are the clear winners in this category. You can’t beat an e-bike for faster average speed and rapidly going from point A to point B. Some e-scooters are incredibly fast, but most are limited to 15 mph in the UK.
Hill Climbing
Most electric bikes can bring the rider up any slope as long as the rider pedals. Some more powerful e-bike motors will propel you up modest hills without pedalling.
The motor does all the work because an electric scooter lacks rider assistance. You may have to push the scooter uphill if you’re a larger rider. I weigh about 230 pounds and have tested e-scooters ranging from 250w to 1200w. Small motors struggle even on short inclines, so you must choose a more powerful type unless you’re pretty light.
Electric bikes must be the clear victor here. If you’re a more significant adult like me, the only acceptable e-scooter will produce more than 1000w. It is less of an issue if you reside in a flat location.
Comfort
E-bikes provide a more comfortable, upright riding position, bigger wheels, and, in some instances, suspension. They also provide a more natural riding experience since you can pedal and swap gears like a standard bike.
Electric scooters are typically ridden standing up, which may be challenging for specific riders on long rides. They also feature smaller wheels that don’t absorb bumps as effectively as restricted suspension travel. They are better suited for short excursions but may not be ideal for long-distance travel. A seat is available on several e-scooters, which can improve comfort.
E-bikes are the winners. I’ve ridden both and can say unequivocally that electric bikes are far more comfortable. However, this is a matter of personal choice.
Practicality
Electric bikes are helpful for commuting, recreational riding, and even workout. They’re also perfect for cycling on various terrain, and their bigger wheel size makes them more stable. If space is an issue, there are many folding e-bikes.
Electric scooters may also be used for commuting because they are portable and can be folded down and transferred into public transportation or stowed in tiny areas. They’re perfect for city living with little storage space.
The winner, in this case, is a tie! E-bikes and e-scooters are both proper modes of personal electric transportation. Although full-size electric bikes are less portable than electric scooters, foldable models abound.
Handling and Safety
Most electric bikes are based on a classic bicycle frame design that has been around for well over a century. The vast wheels roll considerably easier over potholes, kerbstones, and other obstacles than the tiny wheels seen on e-scooters. When negotiating tight curves, wider handlebars provide better control, and solid hydraulic brakes provide superior stopping power.
Because electric scooters have tiny diameter wheels, the handling can be twitchy and anxious. Potholes should be avoided at all costs, and extreme caution should be exercised in rainy conditions – I speak from personal experience!
Electric bikes are the clear victor here! I adore riding e-scooters, although I’m usually a little frightened, especially at more incredible speeds. I’m very aware of my handling limits.
Fitness
This is a sensitive subject in the debate between electric bikes and scooters. Unless you choose a solid electric bike that can be ridden like a moped (throttle and no pedalling), e-bikes are typically considered the best fitness option.
When riding an electric bike in the United Kingdom or Europe, road-legal e-bikes must be pedalled by the user to activate the electric aid. Even while the engine is assisting you, you are still burning calories. According to studies, the typical e-bike user gets the equivalent of a brisk stroll in exercise, which is fantastic for her overall health.
On the other hand, electric scooters only need a little physical effort besides controlling and maintaining the upright riding position. Evidence shows that riding an e-scooter will burn some calories, but not as many as riding an e-bike.
Electric bikes are the clear winners in this category. Many studies have been done on the benefits of riding electric bikes, and the data is precise – as long as you’re pedalling, riding an e-bike is beneficial for fitness and overall health. E-scooters may offer minor advantages but on a different level than riding an e-bike. For further information, read this research on e-scooters.
Legal Constraints
Depending on national and local legislation, e-bikes are subject to varied rules. They are treated similarly to regular bicycles in many countries, allowing them to be ridden on bike lanes without a license or insurance.
Legal limitations for electric scooters vary by region, and in certain places, such as the United Kingdom, they may not be permitted on bike lanes or public roadways unless part of an e-scooter rental program. Before acquiring an electric scooter, make sure to verify your local legislation.
Electric bikes are the clear winners. Unfortunately, other nations, most notably the United Kingdom, have yet to alter their regulations to accommodate e-scooters. Riders of electric scooters in the UK risk having their scooter impounded, fined, and their driving licenses revoked, yet the authorities acknowledge them and usually leave them alone in some regions.
The Bottom Line
Is there a clear victor in the debate between electric bikes and electric scooters? Electric bikes and electric scooters can both be viable modes of transportation. It all comes down to your particular tastes and physical ability. Anything that provides people independence and liberation from the chains of the internal combustion engine is lovely!
When making your decision, keep the legal ramifications in mind. The rules and regulations for e-bikes and e-scooters vary significantly between the United Kingdom and the United States, and even within individual states or localities; it is critical to investigate your local legislation before purchasing. You don’t want to get in trouble with the law and fear punishment or having your e-bike or scooter confiscated.
In this case, I’m all for electric bikes. I’ve ridden a variety of e-scooters over the years and can understand the appeal, but I’m not changing my e-bike for an e-scooter anytime soon!
Thank you for taking the time to read this. Please get in touch with us if you have any questions concerning the subjects covered in this article. Please leave a remark in the space below.
